China | America bad, China good

Chinese propaganda is surprisingly effective abroad

A new study shows how and where China’s message resonates

LONDON, ENGLAND - FEBRUARY 04: President Xi Jinping of China is seen on a programme from the CGTN archive as it plays on a computer monitor on February 04, 2021 in London, England. Ofcom say that Star China Media Limited (SCML) who owns the licence for China Global Television Network (CGTN) doesn't have day-to-day editorial control over the channel, which is against its rules. (Photo by Leon Neal/Getty Images)
The China’s Great and Terrific NetworkImage: Getty Images
|BEIJING

“Experts laud merits of China’s democracy,” read a headline in one of China’s state-owned newspapers last year. “War-addicted West must stop dreaming of global domination by force,” went another. The propaganda churned out by the Communist Party isn’t very subtle—or accurate (China does not hold many elections and it tacitly backs Russia’s unprovoked invasion of Ukraine). But when directed at foreigners, China’s messaging is surprisingly effective, suggests a new study by political scientists at Harvard, Yale and the University of Groningen (in the Netherlands).

The authors surveyed around 6,000 citizens of 19 countries. Participants were split into four groups. The first was shown Chinese propaganda, the second was shown messaging from the American government, the third got a bit of both and the fourth was a placebo group. Before and after watching, participants were asked about the economic and political models of America and China.

This article appeared in the China section of the print edition under the headline "America bad, China good"

Why inflation will be hard to bring down

From the February 18th 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from China

Why China is unlikely to restrain Iran

Officials in Beijing are looking out for China’s interests, not anyone else’s

China’s young people are rushing to buy gold

They seek security in troubled times


China’s ties with Russia are growing more solid

Our columnist visits a future Russian outpost in China’s most advanced spaceport